"Welcome to Buckeye Butters - Where Every Bite is an Adventure! Indulge in our handcrafted, artisanal peanut butter creations that ignite your taste buds and transport you to a world of pure delight. Crafted with passion and perfected with care, our decadent spreads are a celebration of flavor and innovation. Whether you crave a classic creamy blend or crave a daring fusion of sweet and savory, Buckeye Butters has something to satisfy every craving. Join us on a journey of culinary creativity, proudly Mama-owned and inspired by the heart of Ohio. Elevate your snacking experience with Buckeye Butters - Taste the Tradition, Feel the Flavor, Love In Every Bite!"
Order Now

Nut Butter Creations

Tookie Butter
New Flavor Alert
Tookie Butter
$12.95
Say Its Yo Birthday
Say Its Yo Birthday
$12.95
Caramel Crunch Delight
Caramel Crunch Delight
$12.95
Chocolate Covered Pretzel
Chocolate Covered Pretzel
$12.95
Cinna-Mel Toast Crunch
Cinna-Mel Toast Crunch
$12.95
Chocolate Covered Razzberry
Chocolate Covered Razzberry
$12.95
M's Chocolate Pretzel Party
M's Chocolate Pretzel Party
$12.95
Fudgy Brownie Blast
Fudgy Brownie Blast
$12.95
FlufferNutter Swirl
FlufferNutter Swirl
$12.95
Marshmallow Madness
Marshmallow Madness
$12.95
Twixi Stix
Twixi Stix
$12.95
The Lola
The Lola
$12.95
Honey Roasted Peanut Butter
Honey Roasted Peanut Butter
$9.95
You're My Heath-Ro
You're My Heath-Ro
$12.95
Gift card
Gift card
$25.00
Whopp It Like Its Hott
New Flavor Alert
Whopp It Like Its Hott
$12.95
Nut Butter Creations Love in Every Bite

Nut Butter FAQs

We like to call is "Smuncky" because it is somewhere in between Smooth and Chunky, but always made with love
We recommend eating them ASAP, because they are just that good, but within 1 month of opening or 3 months of purchasing. We recommend storing them at room temperature, but they are also really yummy when kept in the refrigerator
Besides Deliciousness, All of the jars have specific nutritional information and can be found on the website under each individual flavor. Please note that products are processed in a facility where egg, milk, soy, wheat, and tree nuts are used in the production of other products.
Since our butter bases are made with all-natural fresh premium roasted nuts, oil separation is normal. Stirring the oils will help them naturally blend, however warmer temperatures do also result in natural separation. The best way to store unopened butter jars is upside down. As a result, you won't have to mix your jar more than once when you open it.

Location

Where the Magic Happens
647 E Market St Akron, Ohio 44304
Contact info
+1 954-495-6750
Buckeye Butters LLC
Cookie settingsReport abuse
Made with